Criticism mounts over video of HDB bomb shelter converted into maid’s quarters

SINGAPORE: A video showcasing a bomb shelter converted into a maid's living space has sparked a heated online debate.

Originally posted on TikTok by a local retailer, the footage features a bunk bed with the maid's sleeping area on the upper level, alongside a small shelf, a ventilation gap, and a louvred sliding door.

Ventilation holes above the bed are also visible.

The video, which had its comments disabled, was later re-uploaded to Reddit on 24 July, under the caption, “HDB bomb shelter with loft bed for helper liveable?”

In response to queries from Shin Min Daily News, the bunk bed retailer disclosed that the custom furniture, which includes the bunk bed, bookshelf, and sliding door, cost approximately S$2,900 (US$2,161).

The retailer noted that many homeowners have requested similar conversions, though ventilation remains a significant challenge.

The current homeowner opted for a customized solution to enhance air circulation.

The retailer endorsed the homeowner’s decision, suggesting that it reflects a commitment to improving living conditions for domestic workers.

Local real estate experts have weighed in on the controversy, highlighting the regulatory aspects of bomb shelter usage.

Real estate agent Jack Sheo (萧文俞), interviewed by Zaobao, explained that while it is common for homeowners to use bomb shelters as maid's rooms, understanding the legal implications is crucial.

“Homeowners cannot rent out bomb shelters as separate rooms,” he explained.

“Moreover, if the original bomb-proof door is removed, it must be reinstalled before the property is sold, as it is specifically designed and must be retained.”

Richard, another seasoned real estate agent, concurred that using bomb shelters for maids can be a more humane solution compared to other arrangements within the flat.

However, he emphasized the importance of adhering to regulations.

“Although it’s not illegal, the Singapore Civil Defence Force may recommend reinstating the original door during inspections,” he added.

Online dispute over converting bomb shelters into maid’s rooms

The use of bomb shelters as maid’s quarters has led to widespread condemnation from netizens on Reddit and The New Paper’s Facebook page.

One user suggested that the homeowner should live in the converted bomb shelter for three months to assess its suitability for a maid.



Another user questioned the legality of such arrangements, arguing that providing a windowless room is inhumane and detrimental to the maid’s well-being.

“How can they perform well if you don’t treat them properly?” the user asked.



Several comments expressed strong opposition to using bomb shelters as living spaces.

A netizen wrote, “No one should be made to stay in a bomb shelter. It seems common because homeowners want helpers but don’t want to sacrifice their own living space.”



They emphasized that domestic helpers are human beings, not slaves, and deserve a proper place to sleep, noting that lack of ventilation is harmful to health.

Some defend using bomb shelters as maid's rooms due to limited space in HDB flats

However, not all responses were critical. Some users defended the practice under certain circumstances.

One comment noted that while the arrangement might not be ideal, it provides the maid with her own space rather than having to share rooms with children or elderly family members.

The comment suggested that given the constraints of HDB flats, such a solution might be the best option when space is limited.



Another comment highlighted the high cost of HDB BTO flats, suggesting that many homeowners cannot afford larger apartments with extra bedrooms to accommodate a maid.