Allianz Securities fraud resurfaces amidst Singaporean concerns over Income Insurance sale

Allianz Global Investors (AGI), a US division of the German insurance giant Allianz, was sentenced in July 2023 by US District Judge Colleen McMahon for a multi-year securities fraud involving private investment funds.

The judgement, which follows AGI’s guilty plea, imposed financial penalties exceeding US$6 billion.

This news has recently resurfaced among Singaporean netizens in private chat groups, coinciding with the impending sale of majority shares (51%) of Income Insurance, formerly NTUC Income, to Allianz, sparking public backlash.

Significant Judgement Outcome

In a press statement, US Attorney Damian Williams highlighted AGI’s failure to uphold its duty to investors, stating, “AGI violated that central tenet and deceived investors by materially understating the risk to which their assets were exposed. This sentence should send a message to the industry: companies will be held responsible when they fail to implement safeguards and ensure that they uphold their duties to investors.”

Background of the Fraud Scheme

The settlement is one of the largest in corporate history and involves both the US Department of Justice (DOJ) and the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

According to US investigators, AGI manipulated investors to place US$11 billion into complex funds known as “Structured Alpha,” which collapsed during the COVID-19 pandemic market downturn in March 2020.

The scheme involved misleading investors about the risk levels and altering documents to present the funds as safer than they were. As a result, AGI collected approximately US$550 million in fees from these funds.

AGI, a subsidiary of Allianz SE, one of the world’s largest financial services firms with over US$2 trillion in assets under management, admitted to federal fraud charges as part of the settlement.

Three of AGI’s portfolio managers, including former Chief Investment Officer Gregoire Tournant, faced criminal charges.

Tournant was indicted for conspiracy, securities fraud, and obstruction of justice, while two other managers, Stephen Bond-Nelson and Trevor Taylor, pleaded guilty to securities fraud in February.

Legal and Financial Repercussions

The court imposed financial penalties exceeding US$6 billion, including over US$463 million in forfeiture, more than US$3.23 billion in restitution, and over US$2.33 billion in fines.

These penalties include restitution to the victims and the forfeiture of dividends paid to AGI’s corporate parent, traceable to the fraudulent activities.

Impact on Investors

The fraudulent scheme affected more than 100 institutional investors, including pension funds for teachers, religious organizations, and other charitable entities.

These funds were exposed to higher risks than promised, leading to significant financial losses during the market sell-off in March 2020.

According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, AGI’s misconduct deprived investors of crucial information about the true risks to which their investments were exposed.

Allianz’s Response and Future Operations

Allianz has stated that the criminal misconduct was perpetrated by a few individuals who no longer work for the company.

As part of the settlement, Allianz is barred from performing advisory services for certain funds in the US.

The company announced a preliminary agreement to transfer the management of about US$120 billion in assets to Voya Financial.

Singaporean Backlash over Impending Sale of Income Insurance

NTUC Income, established in 1970, was created to provide insurance protection to the masses at a time when life insurance was primarily accessible only to the higher-income group.

In January 2022, NTUC Income announced plans to convert its legal structure from a co-operative to a company governed by the Companies Act. It was turned into Income Insurance on 1 September 2022.

Allianz announced on 17 July its intention to purchase 51% of Income Insurance’s shares, offering S$40.58 (US$30.20) per share, with a transaction value of S$2.2 billion.

NTUC Enterprise, currently holding a 72.8% stake in Income Insurance, will remain a substantial shareholder—but a minority—if the sale proceeds.

The re-emergence of the news about AGI’s prosecution reflects public concerns over Allianz’s integrity and the potential implications for local investments, as well as the interests of ordinary shareholders and policyholders if the sale of Income shares goes through.