Singapore netizens discuss closure of heritage sites and concerns over their preservation

SINGAPORE: The closure of heritage sites and old buildings in Singapore has sparked a lively discussion among netizens about the importance of preserving Singapore’s heritage amid ongoing redevelopment.

Many are concerned about the impact of redevelopment on the country’s cultural identity.

Recently, the closure of the Thambi Magazine Store in Holland Village rekindled this discussion.

A beloved establishment cherished by multiple generations, Thambi’s shut down after facing declining demand and insurmountable challenges.

The news of its closure prompted a wave of reactions on social media, with Singaporeans filming, photographing, and lamenting the loss of yet another piece of the nation’s identity.

In a typical reaction, many rushed to make last-minute purchases, driven by a sense of “last chance” urgency.

Terence Heng, a Senior Lecturer in Sociology at the University of Liverpool, weighed in on this issue in a commentary on Channel News Asia.

He argues that these last-minute efforts to preserve memories reflect the deep importance of heritage to the people.

Despite appearing superficial, such actions signify how much the past and heritage mean to society.

However, there is another perspective that views the loss of establishments like Thambi Magazine Store and the old Raffles Junior College campus at Mt. Sinai as inevitable, and in some ways, necessary.

This viewpoint suggests that clinging to the past can hinder progress, particularly economic development.

It sees nostalgia as a hindrance rather than a benefit, especially for places that no longer serve a financial purpose.

Preserving Singapore’s heritage: balancing past and present

Singapore has seen efforts to preserve heritage, such as parts of the Old Police Academy along Thomson Road.

At Bras Basah Complex, Toast Box retained elements of the Music Book Room it replaced, showing how new ventures can emerge from old foundations.

Integrating the past with the present offers more opportunities for societal expression.

Geographers differentiate between ‘space’—the physical environment—and ‘place,’ which is space made meaningful.

The demolition of the old Raffles Junior College campus drew alumni not just for the building but for the memories associated with it.

Intangible memories need tangible places to remain vivid.

Preserving everyday life sites, not just significant landmarks, is crucial to maintaining our heritage.

When preservation is not feasible, communities can creatively reimagine old places.

A recent social experiment transformed the abandoned Peace Centre mall into an arts haven, showcasing grassroots, people-centered initiatives.

Ultimately, while change is inevitable, we can support and cherish beloved places by being regular customers and appreciating our surroundings.

Documenting our experiences can also help preserve memories for the future.