Singapore
TWC2 exposes recruitment scam: S-Pass supervisor ended up with menial work, lower pay
TWC2 spotlights an alleged recruitment scam, where a Bangladeshi worker recruited under the S-Pass as a construction site supervisor, ended up doing menial labour and received significantly lower pay, sometimes less than S$600 per month.
SINGAPORE: Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2), an advocacy group for migrant workers, has shed light on an alleged recruitment scam in Singapore, wherein a migrant worker recruited under the S-Pass scheme found himself receiving salaries far below what was promised by his employer.
TWC2 stresses the urgent need for stringent actions against such recruitment scams and calls upon the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) to implement a robust system ensuring that migrant workers are assigned job roles and compensated exactly as advertised.
Furthermore, the group underscores the potential exploitation of S-Pass requirements and advocates for thorough verification processes to guarantee that job offers made by companies align with their claims and that the salaries provided are accurate.
In a February article, TWC2 shared the story of Mridha Hossein, a Bangladeshi migrant worker who fell victim to an alleged recruitment scam.
Despite being assured a construction site supervisor position with a monthly salary of S$3,050, Mridha was instead subjected to menial labour across various worksites and received significantly lower pay, sometimes less than S$600 per month.
According to TWC2, Mridha, who held a university degree and had prior work experience in Bangladesh, secured a job in Singapore through an agent under the S-Pass scheme, for which he paid S$12,000 in recruitment fees.
A screenshot of an In-principle Approval (IPA) issued to Mridha indicated that he was appointed as a construction site supervisor with a basic monthly salary of S$3,050 along with an S$800 allowance.
Discrepancies between promised and assigned job responsibilities
Mridha expressed his initial optimism upon receiving the In-principle Approval (IPA), envisioning a path to building his career, earning a stable income, and supporting his family.
However, upon his arrival in Singapore in August 2023 and the commencement of his employment, his expectations were shattered.
He soon discovered that the job he was assigned was entirely different from what had been promised to him.
Contrary to expectations, the company allegedly did not possess its own construction projects. Instead, Mridha was deployed as casual labour to various worksites daily.
“For a total of three months I was working here, I worked at different places and different types of work. Sometimes I worked as an electrician, sometimes I’m doing a glass fitting job, sometimes I’m doing construction,” he told TWC2 volunteers in an interview.
“On first time I going for work, I did a painting work. After I finished work, I was really astonished and depressed,” said Mridha.
According to the MOM website, Only eligible candidates will be considered for an S Pass. Criteria include earning a salary of at least S$3,150, which is benchmarked against the top one-third of the local associate professionals and technicians (APT) salaries by age.
Discrepancies in payslips
In October 2023, Mridha’s plight caught the attention of a compassionate stranger who directed him to TWC2 for assistance.
TWC2 then filed a salary complaint with the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) on Mridha’s behalf, recognizing the significant shortfall in his earnings.
Mridha’s payslips revealed a stark disparity between what he was promised and what he actually received. His first paycheck amounted to S$668, with S$148 deducted, leaving him with only S$520 in cash.
Similarly, his second paycheck showed a gross amount of S$697, but after a deduction of S$150, he received just S$547. These figures were a far cry from the promised fixed monthly salary of S$3,850, before overtime.
TWC2 estimated that inclusive of overtime, Mridha was owed approximately S$15,000 in unpaid wages.
TWC2 highlighted Mridha’s encounter with a Tripartite Alliance for Dispute Management (TADM) officer, who allegedly asserted that Mridha, with his S-Pass cancelled by the employer, was under a 30-day Social Visit Pass (SVP) and would need to leave Singapore once the 30-day period expired.
TWC2 criticized TADM for not assuring Mridha of MOM’s policy, which states that workers are not to be repatriated while their claim is pending.
“Moreover, the TADM mediation stage is not the final opportunity for a worker to claim his rightful salary. If an employee finds the settlement offer unacceptably low, he has a right to take the case to the Employment Claims Tribunal (ECT), where he may seek a judgement in his favour.”
Mridha eventually obtained a Special Pass after TWC2 wrote to MOM regarding the matter. Another MOM branch stepped in, possibly due to the severe nature of the employer’s abuse of the In-principle Approval process.
During the ensuing months of November, December, and January (2024), Mridha faced financial hardship as his case lingered on. He was prohibited from seeking new employment due to the conditions of the Special Pass.
Ultimately, MOM succeeded in getting Mridha’s employer to compensate him S$10,000, which he received in full at the beginning of February 2024.
However, Mridha had paid his recruiter around S$12,000 for the job, leaving him still in debt despite the settlement.
Call for stronger measures against recruitment scams
TWC2 emphasized the need for robust measures to prevent recruitment scams like the one experienced by Mridha Hossein.
They stress that while addressing such cases after the fact is important, it’s only part of the solution.
They highlight that Mridha didn’t receive full restitution and suffered significant setbacks to his career aspirations and confidence in Singapore.
TWC2 advocates for a focus on prevention, suggesting that more measures need to be implemented to deter such scams from occurring in the first place.
They propose that companies should be scrutinized more closely, particularly if they cannot demonstrate actual construction contracts but are applying for positions like “Construction Site Supervisor” with high salaries.
Ethan Guo, TWC2’s General Manager, highlights an unusual aspect of S-Pass jobs: the requirement for employers to advertise vacancies locally before hiring foreigners.
He questioned whether the company adhered to the requirement of advertising job vacancies locally before hiring foreigners, pointing out potential gaps in the recruitment process.
“In particular with S-passes, because there’s there the need to ensure that uh locals are protected, and therefore we want to check and ensure that these jobs that the company say they are offering and that they’re paying for is exactly what they say they’re offering.”
“If the poor migrant worker can be cheated, does that mean Singaporeans might potentially be scammed as well?” Mr Guo asked.
Notice to Our Readers: Moving Back to The Online Citizen
Construction worker dies in Changi worksite accident; Driver arrested
Consumers Association of Singapore fined S$20,000 for PDPA breaches following two data security incidents
Singapore’s Yip Pin Xiu secures historic three-peat at Paris Paralympics
Jamus Lim on Minister Chee Hong Tat’s remarks on fiscal policy: Calls for genuine debate over rhetoric
Philippine migrant group in SG hosts successful blood donation drive
China’s ex-convict jailed six years in Singapore for S$6.7M crypto scam
Chee Hong Tat’s call for fiscal prudence rings hollow amid contradictory government spending
UN food agency halts operations in Gaza after vehicle shot by Israeli forces
KL City Hall cancels National Day event following sinkhole incident
Swiss court convicts 2 executives for embezzling S$1.8 billion from 1MDB
This incident, perhaps countless others in the past too, demonstrates factually the non chalance PAP Administration hiding behind their abhorrence of others telling them what to do even with evidences of their mistakes and non involvement – shows ONLY THE TRUE CHARACTER of PAP Administration DICTATORSHIP and ULTRA DISRESPECT of others who love SG, TRYING to PROTECT the good image of SG.
Is this PAP Administration deserve more votes, mandate – Stupid SGpns knows what’s the stupid answer.
Can our million$ manpower minister confirm or deny that such practice is occurring in SG labor market (for past at least 10 years)? Why so quiet, hor? Cannot malu, issit?
YES, BUT -” WHATS WRONG IN COLLECTING MONEY……” mantra prevails..
Wow, now foreigners also underemployed, there is no chance for sgreans.
Aiyoh, such abuse is in our the hiring process for donkey years already, only now TWC2 become aware of it, meh? MOM still acting blur or sotong, hor? Highest paid Manpower minister in the world, yet still can be sotong on such practice? Totally incompetent, indeed. But in overview of management, we cannot fully blame the ministers, it is the really FAILURE of the Boss. Oh, but the Boss is also MOST expensive in the world too, hor. What a scam!
Where is the pappies’ expert on hara-kiri now?
“Ultimately, MOM succeeded in getting Mridha’s employer to compensate him S$10,000, which he received in full at the beginning of February 2024” Comment: what was not stated was what action was taken against the company for its part in submitting a false application to MOM for Mridha’s employment and the slavery-like treatment of him. I don’t count making the employer pay back $10,000 to Mridha as punishment. 1) The employer should be barred from employing migrants for at least one year. 2) In addition to the $10,000 (which was really salary owed) paid to Mridha, a penalty of at least… Read more »
Many of us on TOC have written about the abuse for decades but it is the continued refusal by the Ministers to address this that has caused the slavery to continue. Firstly make all employers to recruit directly from the source. This will remove 2 in betweens. Secondly employers must house the workers themselves not have an agent manage them so the third in between is removed. This will be a win situation for the workers. If certain countries insist that there must be agencies involved, ban the employment from these countries.
This should be unanimously another facet of how they treat foreigners super nice viz a viz local blue Singaporeans.
Anyone forget they said SGpns are dirtier than foreigners. Not least they also scolded SGpns lack spurs, and are less hardworking, so many types of jobs, SGpns are lazy to take up.
This unscrupulous act has existed for decades in Singapore!!! Ahbuden…you people really think foreigners are talents???? Many foreigners who can get their jobs here is because they are cheaper to hire…tied down with contracts like WP/SP/EP…if they are not obedient, their employers will cancel their work permits and order them to take the first flight back home, waiting to be beaten up and killed by creditors back in their own countries because they borrowed money to come here in the first place. On Singapore side, many employment agencies are in cahoot with many employers to scam foreigners to come here.… Read more »
Fake degrees a dozen that foreign talents claimed to possess were excellently brushed off by MoEdn/MoM – those said degrees were not relevant to the jobs. When the important issue is HONESTY or FRAUD – tax payers has to foot the bill most of the time for dishonesty and fraudulent behaviors that has costs attached – the custodians of SG Reserves, simply ignored corruption swimming everywhere even right in front of their sights. If they admit to what a spade is a spade is, they won’t do so bcz it’s tantamount to ownself harakiri ownself. That’s why we have Ridout… Read more »
If this is happening with the “S-Pass” what makes you think that similar things are not happening with the other employment “Passes.”
Furthermore, which construction sites were he working at? Were any government companies or their cronies involved? Considering that construction is dominated by the government and their cronies, I would not be surprised.
This should be investigated further.
This is just FAKE news. If fxxkers like this trouble maker TWC can show proof and there is evidence to prosecute then got talk. In any case, why your country has such a need for these low ses foreign workers ,is SIMPLY YOU LOCALS DO NOT WANT TO DO SUCH JOBS AND YET WANT YOUR LOW SES BTO, MRT.etc….fast..and cheap! Why truly First World country do not need such workers and the locals there do these jobs? Instead local fuxkers rather cow peh cow bu than to pick up a hammer drill or what’s not, to do such physically demanding… Read more »
This has been a norm for years but MOM chose to look the other way. That is why the job market is bad. The crooked employers hire these cheap but on paper states they’re FT and are in the top category. In the first place, does SG not have supervisors? That’s a big give away.
Only S-Pass? I think Employment Pass also have such behind the scenes mo dy back.
Especially now the minimum sum is going to go up in 2025
God damn it.
Woe betide me.
How come I cannot comprehend the answer to my own curiousity as to what Tan See Lengs job is, that make himself a Multi Millionaire with the Millions of Dollars of salaries he enjoy, courtesy of the Administration.
So it seems TWC2 is doing the policing work, justice work (investigations, interview, advocacy) of the arrogant ownself deflect ownself MOM.
Wow to work in MoM is truly heavenly, d best job in SG.