Singapore
Reddit post alerts to potentially unfair retrenchment practices at major insurance firm
A Reddit post has sparked allegations of potential unfair practices at a major insurance company that has recently been in the media spotlight, with claims suggesting that employees might have been coerced into resigning without compensation as a means to avoid formal retrenchment. The post has led to speculation and discussions about the legal and ethical implications of such tactics.
![Reddit post alerts to potentially unfair retrenchment practices at major insurance firm](https://gutzymedia.s3.ap-northeast-2.amazonaws.com/wp/2024/08/15205611/image-3.jpg)
SINGAPORE: A Reddit post by user “jst-my-2cnt” on Wednesday (14 Aug) has raised serious concerns about alleged unfair practices at a prominent insurance company.
The user shared the story of friends employed at the company, who were allegedly coerced into resigning from their positions without proper compensation.
The Redditor began by expressing hesitation about sharing the information but felt it was important to shed light on what they described as a harsh reality of the current job market.
“I’ve been thinking for a while whether to post this. I hesitated a lot initially, but I think it’s fair to let people know the realities of the world we call home,” the user wrote.
In the post entitled, “My friends working for an insurer with some media attention lately have been asked to resign, as there are no more jobs for them,” the Redditor described how one friend was summoned to a meeting with a superior, where he was criticized for his “subpar” work performance.
The superior reportedly informed the employee that his position had been made redundant and that he would need to resign, with no offer of compensation.
The superior allegedly threatened the employee with a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) if he refused to resign and warned that his reputation would be tarnished if he didn’t leave quietly.
Following the meeting, Human Resources also inquired about the employee’s resignation plans.
The user noted that similar incidents of threats and pressure were reported by other employees within the company.
According to the post, the company recently announced a cost-cutting project and reorganization, which seemed to target certain employees for resignation without providing proper retrenchment benefits.
“Any suggestion on what they can do? Some have decided to quietly resign as they see no better way out,” the user asked the Reddit community.
Redditors suggest actions for addressing unfair retrenchment
Under the post, many Redditors shared their thoughts on the situation, offering various courses of action for those affected.
One commenter recommended reporting the issue to the Ministry of Manpower (MOM), stating it is inappropriate to pressure employees into resigning without a justifiable cause.
They emphasized that if the issue is performance-related, the company should set performance milestones, or if the role is redundant, the company should opt for retrenchment.
Another commenter suggested recording any conversations with management, particularly if there are threats involved, and reporting these incidents to the relevant authorities.
They advised having a recording device ready during unannounced meetings with supervisors to collect evidence of any threats, which could be used to take the case to MOM or pursue legal action.
Some commenters advised against resigning and recommended allowing the Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) process to take its course, noting that the company must provide valid reasons for termination.
One Redditor explained that in their company, PIP is a last resort, with Human Resources (HR) participating in the interview process alongside the manager.
The manager must provide solid evidence to support their case, such as timestamped photos or office entry logs in the case of tardiness.
No legal obligation for retrenchment benefits in Singapore
However, some Redditors pointed out that there is no legal requirement for companies to provide retrenchment benefits.
One commenter questioned the legality of firing employees without compensation for subpar work.
Another responded by stating that while immediate termination without compensation is rare, employers are typically required to provide a notice period or one month’s salary in compensation.
They clarified that firing someone on the spot without compensation usually occurs only in cases of criminal activity.
Speculation mounts over unnamed insurance firm in Reddit allegations, supected to Income Insurance or Allianz
Commenters speculated on the specific company involved, suggesting the situation might pertain to Income Insurance or Allianz, whose circumstances are uncannily similar given the media attention they have received over the proposed sale of the majority shares.
They noted that in Singapore, there are no legally mandated retrenchment benefits, only guidelines from the Tripartite Alliance for Fair and Progressive Employment Practices (TAFEP).
As a result, it is legal to retrench employees without benefits, especially if the redundancy can be justified, such as in a corporate takeover.
Another wrote, “Not surprising there… they gave up control of the company. The first thing is cost cutting in all M&A. They call it “business synergy” In layman’s terms is. Fire the extras and the ones left take on more job”
The proposed acquisition of Income Insurance by Allianz for S$2.2 billion (US$1.6 billion) has raised concerns among Members of Parliament and the public about its potential impact on the National Trades Union Congress (NTUC)’s social mission and its employees.
During a parliamentary session on 6 August, Minister of State Alvin Tan assured parliament that NTUC remains committed to its mission of caring for workers and fulfilling its social responsibilities.
MP He Ting Ru (WP-Sengkang) raised specific concerns about the proposed deal and its potential impact on the 1,900 employees of NTUC Income.
She questioned how the deal and subsequent restructuring would affect the workforce, particularly the more junior staff.
“It is natural that existing staff, especially those who are more junior, will be concerned and wonder whether and how they will be supported through this,” Ms He stated during the session.
In response, Deputy Chairman of the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), Chee Hong Tat, advised caution and noted that the deal has not yet been approved.
He emphasized that while MAS does not regulate the employment practices of financial institutions, it expects these institutions to comply with employment laws and guidelines.
![](https://gutzy.asia/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Gutzy-Logo-whiteS.png)
-
Politics2 weeks ago
Jamus Lim on Minister Chee Hong Tat’s remarks on fiscal policy: Calls for genuine debate over rhetoric
-
Community2 weeks ago
Toast Box faces backlash and boycott calls amid price increases
-
Media1 week ago
Notice to Our Readers: Moving Back to The Online Citizen
-
Singapore2 weeks ago
Singapore introduces new scheme in April 2025 offering up to S$6,000 in financial support for retrenched workers
-
Politics2 weeks ago
Jamus Lim raises concerns over high cost of living and its impact on Singaporeans’ sense of belonging
-
Opinion2 weeks ago
Chee Hong Tat’s call for fiscal prudence rings hollow amid contradictory government spending
-
Singapore2 weeks ago
Tan Suee Chieh: Sacrificing NTUC Income’s values for short-term gains undermines its foundation
-
Comments2 weeks ago
Netizens raise skepticism over Inclusiveness of Singapore’s new Jobseeker Support scheme
Every month start earning more than $12,000 by doing very simple Online job from home. I’m doing this job in my part time i sd1 have earned and received $12429 last month .I’m now a good Online earner and earns enough cash for my needs. Every person can get this Online job pop Over…
Here This Site—>>> Www.NetPay1.Com
Get Out of My Elite Uncaring Face: Welcome To The Real Corporate World.
Start now making every month extra $19k or more by just doing an easy online job from home. Last month I earned and received $16650 from this job by giving only 3 hrs. a day. Every person can now get this job and start earning online by:-
Open This…. Www.yourjobs1.online
Fantastic work Since I presently earn over $46K a month from just legal internet activities, I enjoy your job. I am aware that you are now making a sizeable amount of money online with just $38K, and that these are straightforward administrative jobs.
Detail Here——————>>> Www.NetPay1.Com
Slaves have zero rights.
This fella trying to be a whistle blower is definitely a Sinkie.
Kenna kick out of his job, only will cow peh cow bu.
Why like that?
Lose this lousy job, get another loh!
Cannot leh
Sinkie are too lame and useless to fight in their own job market IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY!
CECA to FTs from don’t know where coming here, laughing like mad from their condo balcony!
You locals should be ashamed.
Better pack up and head to ….some mountain in Bhutan and clear their minds and find where they misplaced their balls then come back!
O.K?😆😆😆😆🤣🤣🤣😆😆😆
If the Allianz deal goes through, even top management if redundant will have to leave. German corporates are run efficiently and effectively. The objective is profits.
The script is there – assurances are….?
How to escape – telling lies in Parliament is nothing, but it’s fatal for opposition bcz AG and SPF weaponised as deadly tools against Opposition camps.
Predictably lying assurances are actual lies?
Even before the sale Is completed, this forced retrenchment is happening. Imagine when the Sale and Purchase is completed and NTUC Enterprise is no longer major shareholder, the future 51% shareholder is not obliged to listen let alone honour their commitment. Game over.
World famous Tripartite to the R E S C U E – Uniquely Singapore.